I completely missed this – “The Powerful and the Pure” is a Mills & Boon’s (or Harlequin’s, depending on which side of the pond you sit) miniseries inspired by classic literary romances, including EMMA, PRIDE AND PREJUDICE, JANE EYRE, and WUTHERING HEIGHTS.

I love the concept and EMMA is probably my favourite Austen, so I obviously had to read Kate Hewitt‘s take on it.  After a couple of false starts (tip – it’s THE MATCHMAKER BRIDE in the States, but MR AND MISCHIEF in the UK), I downloaded it onto my Kindle* and ahhh, fun read.

I did wonder how this would read to someone not familiar with EMMA because really, I had the original novel and its characters and plot at the back of my mind more often than not, comparing and contrasting the two.

Did this detract from my reading experience?  I think not.  There were just enough allusions to the original novel to delight me, while Emily and Jason were more than enough to hold my attention in their own right – I certainly didn’t view them as mere fascimiles of Emma and Mr Knightley.  In a way, having read EMMA may even have added to my enjoyment of MR AND MISCHIEF – being familiar with the eventual relationship between Emma and Mr Knightley made me love Emily and Jason’s interactions even more, right from the start.  I did think Emily came across as more sympathetic than Emma (while still retaining that I-know-best personality), which is probably a good thing in a book constrained by category romance word count limits.

Friends-to-lovers is one of my favourite tropes, and having that bit of history between Emily and Jason made the chemistry and romance even more satisfying, while the London background was a lovely way of bringing EMMA into the present-day.  Emily’s insta-friendship with the receptionist struck me as slightly off (Emily being the head of HR), but then again, Emma’s friendship with Harriet in Austen’s novel was probably just as unlikely, and the office setting – unlikely friendships aside – hit the right note (one of my pet peeves is anachronisms in office settings, which used to be prevalent in M&Bs**).

I thought Ms Hewitt’s MR AND MISCHIEF did an excellent job of capturing the key themes and the spirit of the original novel, while translating EMMA into a category romance.  I really enjoyed this book and am planning on reading the rest of the “inspired by” books, especially if they’re all just as good.  And I hope there will be more than four in this series.


*I also love the fact that you now no longer have to buy category romances within the first few months before they disappear forever – yay for ebooks!

**I’ve not been reading many M&Bs recently, so have no idea whether this is still the case or not – I think this tends to be author-specific actually.

2 thoughts on “Kate Hewitt’s MR AND MISCHIEF

  1. Hi Li!

    This sounds pretty interesting! I’ll check it out, although I’m really not familiar with Emma. Actually, I’m not familiar with any of the Jane Austen books ^_^;

    LOL, I second on the ebooks for category romances! It makes it soooo much easier! LOL.

    • Yes, it is bliss being able to track down authors’ backlists so easily. I’m not reading very many though – I remember when I used to borrow six-plus from the library at one time and finish them in a week… now it’s more like six a year. Oh well.

      And I do wonder how this would read to someone not familiar with EMMA – I’d love to know if you feel the same connection I did. While I’ve probably read all of Jane Austen’s novels, I’m most familiar with P&P and EMMA. And I’ve got to be in the right mood to read them, else I just don’t get into the story. Having said that, I’ve downloaded PERSUASION to do a re-read ahead of Diana Peterfreund’s YA retelling next year!

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.